Excited to share here my annual post of recommendations for books on Catholic history, literature, and religion tied to the time period we will be studying with the CMEC this year: roughly 1780-1900 in American and British/European history, alongside ancient Rome.
For previous years' recommendations, check out my Catholic History and Religion archive. At this point, I have written posts every era! I have shared about this period before, but I have reorganized and refreshed my previous suggestions here and added a few new ones.
This post is organized into the following categories: Bible for all Forms, Catholic Historical Supplements for Forms 1-3, Religion for Forms 1-3, and Catholic Historical Supplements and Religion for Forms 4 & 5 (High School).
BIBLE
Lower FormsThe CMEC follows the PNEU in scheduling Paterson-Smyth's books as a complementary resource for Bible lessons, and I will be using them in my preparation as well. I don't agree with everything Paterson-Smyth writes, but he offers good "captain ideas" for Bible lessons that get at the overarching themes of the assigned Bible texts.
- Dummelow's One-Volume Bible Commentary - This PNEU-recommended commentary has a good amount of historical details for each book. (This is the new edition -- we have an older used one.)
- Navarre's Major Prophets and Minor Prophets have served my older kids well throughout their Old Testament studies.
This coming year, we will be studying roughly 1780-1800 (beginning with the French Revolution through Reconstruction after the Civil War). My Form 2A and 3 students will also be studying ancient Rome.
- Windeatt's The Miraculous Medal (on Catherine Laboure), The Little Flower (on St. Therese), The Cure of Ars (on John Vianney), and Pauline Jaricot
- Keyes' Mother Cabrini: Missionary to the World (or save for next year)
- Osiek's Saint Rose Philippine Duchesne: A Heart on Fire Across Frontiers
- Powers-Waters' Mother Seton and the Sisters of Charity
- Beebe's Saint John Bosco and Saint Dominic Savio (a favorite of my sons!)
- Mother Mary Eleanor's The Last Apostle (out of print, to tie to our reading in ancient Rome)
- Garnett's Florence Nightingale's Nuns
- Smaridge's Hands of Mercy: The Story of Sister-Nurses in the Civil War (I have an old copy)
- Heagney's Chaplain in Gray: Abram Ryan
- Lomask's General Phil Sheridan and the Union Calvary
- Hurley's John Hughes, Eagle of the Church
- Hopkins' Black Robe Peacemaker: Pierre De Smet
- Bartelme's Simon Brute and the Western Adventure
- de Wohl's St. Helena and the True Cross (he also wrote an adult version, linked under High School)
- Betz' Knight of Molokai and Yankee at Molokai (both out of print, unfortunately)
Arnold-Forster's A History of England and H.E. Marshall's Our Island Story are both written from a British, Anglican perspective. I love the books and think they are certainly worth using! I can't really imagine our homeschool without them. However, I do generally edit here and there and supplement with Catholic reading as described above for a more balanced view. With this approach, I think my students get to understand how the viewpoint of the author colors his or her work.
Each week I have a half-hour religion slot in which I work with my Form 1 & 2 students (with my Form 3 students joining in some weeks, reading independently some weeks). We read aloud, add to notebooks, memorize prayers and catechism, etc.
- Two books by Mother Mary Loyola: The Soldier of Christ: Talks Before Confirmation (for both) and Home for Good (just for my daughter)
- Preparation for Confirmation (very slim book with just the basics, cheaper to buy directly from Angelus Press)
- They also will be reading about the saints as they discern their Confirmation names!
My Form 3 students will read a book a term for additional Sunday reading:
This year, we will continue A Character Calendar, which has been a favorite with my younger students. I read this at breakfast time, so my older kids listen in too. Many of the mottoes from A Character Calendar have found their way into my students' motto books!
- Selections from Carroll's The Revolution Against Christendom: 1650-1823 and The Crisis of Christendom: 1815-2005 (This series is not perfect by any means -- my kids get frustrated with Carroll's voice sometimes. But it is thorough and does a good job setting up the major issues of each period. We'll be reading Chapers 8-end of Revolution and 1-6 of Crisis.)
- Belloc's The French Revolution (my kids love his style -- this may end up being a free read because Carroll is pretty long)
Spiritual classics written during the period:
- Daily Thoughts of Mother Seton
- Msgr. Benson's The Friendship of Christ (our priest has been quoting from this off and on for the past year, and we love Benson's fiction, so I want to give this a try)
- Selected Sermons, Prayers, and Devotions from John Henry Newman
- The Sermons of the Cure d'Ars (mine will be alternating between the St. Francis de Sales sermons listed below and these, depending on the liturgical season, reading one weekly)
- Farrow's Damien the Leper (scheduled by the CMEC as one of their term biographies)
- The Life Of Father De Smet S.J.: Apostle Of The Rocky Mountains (good American biography for us)
- Venerable Fr. Germanus' The Life of St. Gemma Galgani (one of my favorite saints)
- St. John Bosco: The Friend of Youth and Forty Dreams of St. John Bosco
- The Story of a Soul: the Autobiography of St. Therese of Lisieux (another personal favorite!)
- Father O'Sullivan's St. Philomena: the Wonder-Worker (her bones were discovered in the 1800s and she lived in ancient Roman times)
- de Wohl's The Living Wood: A Novel about Saint Helena and the Emperor Constantine (another de Wohl novel -- takes place in the later days of the Roman Empire) and The Spear: A Novel about the Crucifizion
- Gertrude von le Fort's Song of the Scaffold (a thought-provoking novella what provides a new perspective on the French Revolution)
- Sienkiewiczk's Quo Vadis (to connect to our Ancient Rome)
- Willa Cather's Death Comes for the Archbishop (assigned by the CMEC in Term 3)
- Poetry of Gerard Manley Hopkins and Francis Thompson (assigned by the CMEC in Term 3)
- Benson's The Necromancer (we have enjoyed Msgr. Benson's books but I have not personally read this one yet)
- Lewis' The Screwtape Letters
- Chesterton's The Everlasting Man
- Fulton Sheen's Life of Christ
- Msgr. Hugh Benson's The Friendship of Christ (a favorite of mine)
- Fr. Jacques' Philippe's Searching for and Maintaining Peace
- Father d'Elbee's I Believe in Love (after our reading of Story of a Soul)
- Fr. Laux's Catholic Morality and Catholic Apologetics (for catechesis)
~~~
I hope this helps those studying this time period with us this fall!
Any wonderful books I should add to the list above? Let me know in the comments!
(Amazon links above are affiliate links. Thanks for your support!)





Yay! I have been refreshing your page often as I eagerly awaited this annual post! Thank you, dear Celeste, for all of your time and energy that goes into sharing this with us all! May Our good Lord bless you and your homeschool richly this upcoming year.
ReplyDeleteI'm glad it's helpful, Kayla! Thank you so much for the prayers!
DeleteThank you for all your work! A question on First Communion Prep- We have always used The King of the Golden City. How does Mother Loyola’s First Communion book compare to the King of the Golden City?
ReplyDeleteHi Jenna! The King of the Golden City is a lovely allegorical tale, whereas First Communion is a longer book all about the spiritual life for children. It is truly wonderful. You can read it online here: https://archive.org/details/firstcommunion00loyouoft/page/n9/mode/2up Mother Loyola has so many good books that we have used over the years. I so appreciate her writing.
DeleteHi Celeste, can you comment on the perspective I might take with my Form 4 student reading Travels with A Donkey through Cevennes by Robert Louis Stevenson. I was disturbed by seemingly antiCatholic scene at the monastery where he viewed efforts to covert him to Catholicism very negatively and harshly. And later in the book he seems to push the idea that all faiths that are honest are as the same. Am I understanding this correctly? I figure there's a reason I'm not picking up on a to the merits of this book selection by the CMEC, who has guided us to do many wonderful books over our years.
ReplyDeleteI live in a mixed faith house and had to have a conversation already about my obligations as a parent passing on the faith vs strangers trying to convert one who's not asking.
Do you think I should substitute the book or let her finish it and carry on more conversations and RSL's wrestling with faith in this book set in an area of religious conflict.
Hi Lalli,
DeleteI agree that some of Stevenson's critiques can be off-putting at first, but I do think it's a book worth reading and discussing with high school students. We might consider first whether Stevenson is making fair points -- as you said, is there a difference in the way we pass on the faith as parents, and the approach taken in the text when Stevenson visits the monastery? Are there times when evangelization takes the wrong tack? What ought we consider in this work? On the other hand, Stevenson has his own issues, which are worth thinking about too: Do these critiques stem from his own issues with Catholicism (England has been deeply anti-Catholic for several centuries now)? Does he feel the same about the Protestants he meets in, as you said, this very religiously complicated region? Is his perspective fair, or is it rooted in his existing biases? And we can consider the region itself too, and how it handles religious differences -- Does the system they have of separating by religion work well? What seem to be the downsides of splitting along religious lines and forming independent communities, with little contact with others?
But the really interesting connection will be in Term 3, when high school students read the biography of St. Damien. Stevenson wrote one of the letters in defense of Damien and it is a beautiful testament to the holiness of this saint. It makes you wonder how Stevenson went from his critiques in this text to the account he offers! https://media.benedictine.edu/robert-louis-stevensons-remarkable-defense-of-st-damien-of-molokai.
I hope this helps give some perspective, whichever way you decide to go with the book!